Also a lot of people are now touting the value of a raw diet. I am not one to follow the latest fads as so often we find out these things were not as good as some originally thought. Feeding raw meat to dogs is risky as we all have been warned time and time again about bacteria that can cause illnesses and even death from meat sources that are not cooked to proper temperatures. Yes, I know that if they lived in the wild they would be eating raw meat. But, consider how many wild animals die early deaths from improper nutrition, diseases and injury. Your dog is no longer a wild animal, the dog has been domesticated for hundreds of years and depends on us to provide for him. And how many of us are willing for at least 50-75% of our dogs to not survive their first year? That is the outcome in the wild.
No, the answer lies somewhere in between all these ideas. We need to do our research and stop believing the advertising campaigns that put on the television commercials. The answer to that is simple, they want to sell us something. Who do we believe? I am not selling you any dog food, I just want you to be as informed as possible so you can make the right choices for your dog to have a long and healthy life. Look over the information and decide for yourself. But this gives you an idea of how dog foods rank and a place to start.
Looking at the ingredients of your dog's food, find the ingredient listed on the table below. Starting with 100 points, add or subract the points given for each ingredient and total the points. Print this sheet to total your points for each item & then grade scale is listed at the end of the table. At the bottom of this page you can also see the Grading Results for Major or Popular dog foods listed below by Brand and by Score. Check it out, I was quite surprised by the results. Print Table Here
| INGREDIENT |
Points
(Add or Subtract) |
New Score |
| For every listing of "By-Product" |
-10 |
|
| For every Non-Specific Animal Source ("Meat" or "Poultry", Meat, Meal or Fat) reference |
-10 |
|
| For every Grain "Mill Run" or Non-Specific Grain Source |
- 5 |
|
Same Grain ingredient used 2 or more times in the first 5 ingredients.
(example: ground brown rice, brewer's rice, and rice flour are all the same grain) |
- 5 |
|
| Corn listed in the top 5 ingredients |
-2 |
|
| Protein Sources are not meat meal and there are less than 2 meats in the top 3 ingredients |
- 3 |
|
| If Lamb is the only animal protein source (unless your dog is allergic to other protein sources) |
- 2 |
|
| Food is Baked NOT Extruded |
+ 5 |
|
| Food is endorsed by any major breed group or nutritionist |
+ 5 |
|
| Animal sources are hormone-free and antibiotic-free |
+ 2 |
|
| Vegetables have been tested for pesticides and ARE Pesticide-Free |
+ 1 |
|
| Any of the meat sources are Organic |
+ 5 |
|
| For every different specific animal protein source, other than the 1st one.
(example: Count "chicken" & "chicken meal" as only 1 protein source, BUT count "chicken" & "fish" as 2 different sources) |
+ 1 |
|
| IF THE FOOD CONTAINS THE FOLLOWING: |
| BHA, BHT, or Ethoxyquin |
- 10 |
|
| Any Artificial Colorants |
- 3 |
|
| Ground Corn or Whole Grain Corn |
- 3 |
|
| Any Animal Fat (other than Fish Oil) |
- 2 |
|
| Soy or Soybeans |
- 2 |
|
| Salt |
- 1 |
|
| Wheat (unless you know that your dog isn't allergic to wheat) |
- 2 |
|
| Beef (unless you know that your dog isn't allergic to beef) |
- 1 |
|
| Fruit |
+ 3 |
|
| Barley |
+ 2 |
|
| Probiotics |
+ 3 |
|
| Vegetables (NOT Corn or Other Grains) |
+ 3 |
|
| Flax Seed Oil (not just the seeds) |
+ 2 |
|
| Oats or Oatmeal |
+ 1 |
|
| Sunflower Oil |
+ 1 |
|
| Glucosamine & Chondroitin |
+ 1 |
|
TOTAL POINTS HERE |
|
100+ = A+ 94-100 = A
86-93 = B
78-85 = C
70-77 = D
69-below = F
Alphabetically by Brand |
| Brand |
Score |
Grade |
Authority Harvest Baked |
116 |
A+ |
Bil-Jac Select |
68 |
F |
Canidae |
112 |
A+ |
| Chicken Soup Senior |
115 |
A+ |
| Diamond Maintenance |
64 |
F |
| Diamond Lamb Meal & Rice |
92 |
B |
| Diamond Large Breed 60+ Formula |
99 |
A |
| Dick Van Patten's Natural Balance Ultra Premium |
122 |
A+ |
| Dick Van Patten's Duck and Potato |
106 |
A+ |
| Eagle Pack Holistic |
119 |
A+ |
| Eagle Pack Holistic Chicken |
114 |
A+ |
| Eagle Pack Large and Giant Breed Puppy |
94 |
A |
| Eagle Pack Natural |
94 |
A |
| Eukanuba Large Breed Adult |
83 |
C |
| Eukanuba Natural Lamb and Rice |
87 |
B |
| Flint River Ranch (non-specific fat source) |
92 |
B |
| Foundations |
106 |
A+ |
| Hund-n-Flocken Adult Dog (lamb) by Solid Gold |
93 |
A |
| Iams Lamb Meal & Rice Formula Premium |
73 |
D |
| Iams Large Breed |
83 |
C |
| Innova Dog |
114 |
A+ |
| Innova Evo |
114 |
A+ |
| Kirkland Signature Chicken, Rice, and Vegetables |
110 |
A+ |
| Kirkland Signature Puppy Chicken, Rice and Vegetable |
108 |
A+ |
| Natural Balance Duck and Potato |
114 |
A+ |
| Nutrisource Lamb and Rice |
87 |
B |
| Nutro Chicken, Rice, & Oatmeal (non-specific fat source) |
85 |
C |
| Nutro Natural Choice Large Breed Puppy |
87 |
B |
| Nutro Natural choice Lamb and Rice |
85 |
C |
| Ol Roy |
9 |
F |
| Pedigree Complete Nutrition |
42 |
F |
| Pedigree Adult Complete |
14 |
F |
| Pet Gold Adult with Lamb & Rice |
23 |
F |
| Pro Plan All Breed |
68 |
F |
| Pro Plan Natural Turkey & Barley |
103 |
A+ |
| Purina Beneful |
17 |
F |
| Purina Dog |
62 |
F |
| Purina Come-n-Get It |
16 |
F |
| Royal Canin Bulldog |
100 |
A+ |
| Royal Canin Dachshund 28 Formula |
97 |
A |
| Royal Canin Natural Blend Adult |
106 |
A+ |
| Sensible Choice Chicken and Rice |
97 |
A |
| Science Diet Advanced Protein Senior 7+ |
63 |
F |
| Science Diet chicken adult maintenance |
45 |
F |
| Science Diet for Large Breed Puppies |
69 |
F |
| Solid Gold Bison |
123 |
A+ |
| Timberwolf Organics Lamb and Venison |
136 |
A+ |
| Wellness Just for Puppy |
117 |
A+ |
| Wellness Super5 Mix Chicken |
110 |
A+ |
| Solid Gold Wolfking Adult Dog (Bison) |
97 |
A |
Numerical by Score |
| Brand |
Score |
Grade |
|
136 |
A+ |
| Solid Gold Bison |
123 |
A+ |
| Dick Van Patten's Natural Balance Ultra Premium |
Score 122 |
A+ |
| Eagle Pack Holistic |
Score 119 |
A+ |
| Wellness Just for Puppy |
Score 117 |
A+ |
| Authority Harvest Baked |
Score 116 |
A+ |
| Chicken Soup Senior |
Score 115 |
A+ |
| Eagle Pack Holistic Chicken |
Score 114 |
A+ |
| Innova Dog |
Score 114 |
A+ |
| Innova Evo |
Score 114 |
A+ |
| Natural Balance Duck and Potato |
Score 114 |
A+ |
| Canidae |
Score 112 |
A+ |
| Kirkland Signature Chicken, Rice, and Vegetables |
Score 110 |
A+ |
| Wellness Super5 Mix Chicken |
Score 110 |
A+ |
| Kirkland Signature Puppy Chicken, Rice and Vegetable |
Score 108 |
A+ |
| Dick Van Patten's Duck and Potato |
Score 106 |
A+ |
| Royal Canin Natural Blend Adult |
106 |
A+ |
| Foundations |
106 |
A+ |
| ProPlan Natural Turkey & Barley |
103 |
A+ |
| Royal Canin Bulldog |
100 |
A+ |
| Diamond Large Breed 60+ Formula |
99 |
A |
| Royal Canin Dachshund 28 Formula |
97 |
A |
| Sensible Choice Chicken and Rice |
97 |
A |
| Solid Gold Wolfking Adult Dog (Bison) |
97 A |
A |
| Eagle Pack Large and Giant Breed Puppy |
94 A |
A |
| Eagle Pack Natural |
94 A |
A |
| Solid Gold Hund-n-Flocken Adult Dog (lamb) |
93 A |
A |
| Diamond Lamb Meal & Rice |
92 B |
B |
| Flint River Ranch (non-specific fat source) |
92 B |
B |
| Eukanuba Natural Lamb and Rice |
87 B |
B |
| Nutrisource Lamb and Rice |
87 B |
B |
| Nutro Natural Choice Large Breed Puppy |
87 |
B |
| Nutro Chicken, Rice, & Oatmeal (non-specific fat source) |
85 |
C |
| Nutro Natural choice Lamb and Rice |
85 |
C |
| Eukanuba Large Breed Adult |
83 |
C |
| Iams Large Breed |
83 |
C |
| Iams Lamb Meal & Rice Formula Premium |
73 |
D |
| Science Diet for Large Breed Puppies |
69 |
F |
| Bil-Jac Select |
68 |
F |
| Pro Plan All Breed |
68 |
F |
| Diamond Maintenance |
64 |
F |
| Science Diet Advanced Protein Senior 7+ |
63 |
F |
| Purina Dog |
62 |
F |
| Science Diet chicken adult maintenance |
45 |
F |
| Pedigree Complete Nu |
42 |
F |
| Pet Gold Adult with Lamb & Rice |
23 |
F |
| Purina Beneful |
17 |
F |
| Purina Come-n-Get It |
16 |
F |
| Pedigree Adult Complete |
14 |
F |
| Ol Roy |
9 |
F |